An image of a cardboard box sitting on a raised stone step in front of a front door. The box has a red sticker on the side that says 'fragile'. The box has a crumpled corner and looks like it has been damaged. This image was created for use on our website, but has now been realsed under the Creative
Photo by Meanwell Packaging on Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 2.0

Returns & Refunds

Part of Dropshipping supplier agreements

Agreeing on responsibility for damaged shipments

Set supplier duties for damage evidence, packing, claims, credits and replacement costs while handling the customer's rights separately.

This is an editorial pen name used by the publication, not a claim of an independently verified personal identity. Original editorial credit: Desk Customer Care.

undefined

Set a written default for who gathers evidence, contacts the carrier, arranges a replacement or credit, and pays each cost when a shipment arrives damaged. Keep the store responsible for the customer case while any supplier or carrier claim is investigated.

Give the store a way to respond to its customer while any supplier or carrier claim is investigated. A dented carton alone does not establish product damage, and visible damage does not always show where it occurred.

Separate the customer case from the supplier claim

Ask what arrived and what is affected. Record the order line, product and variant, delivery date, item and packaging condition, and useful photographs. Check proof of purchase: the ACCC says this can include a receipt, a credit or debit card statement, or a lay-by agreement (ACCC). Request only evidence needed to assess the problem; a damaged carton, broken item and missing component may call for different questions.

Record what the customer says and the remedy they are seeking. A damaged product may fail the acceptable quality consumer guarantee under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). Consumer Affairs Victoria says the remedy may be a refund, repair or replacement depending on whether the problem is major or minor; in its major-failure example, the customer could choose a refund or replacement (Consumer Affairs Victoria).

Decide the customer's response separately from whether the supplier or carrier later accepts a claim. Do not wait for that commercial dispute to be settled before managing the customer case.

Allocate responsibilities and costs

Use this written allocation as the operating default: the store owns customer contact, decides and arranges the consumer remedy, and pursues recovery separately. The supplier provides dispatch, packing and product records, and lodges the carrier claim only if the agreement assigns it that task; otherwise, the store lodges it. Consumer Affairs Victoria says the seller is responsible for resolving delivery issues with Australia Post or the courier (Consumer Affairs Victoria).

Agree how the parties will decide disputed causes and who gathers the evidence for that decision. The supplier and carrier may give different accounts of packing and transport, so name an escalation contact and require a response that identifies the evidence relied on and the next step.

Write a commercial cost rule into the supplier agreement. For example, agree that the supplier credits the product cost and replacement freight when a product or packing fault is established, and pursue transit-damage recovery through the carrier under its terms. Name who advances replacement costs and pays return freight, inspection, handling, safe disposal and any unrecovered amount, with the evidence required and settlement timing.

Check the supplier contract and any Incoterm for when commercial risk transfers and how transport costs are allocated. Incoterms do not replace a contract covering remedies and disputes, and the customer-facing position may still be governed by the Australian Consumer Law (Sprintlaw).

Check packing, risk and insurance assumptions

Specify packing requirements for the relevant product, including protection for fragile parts, secure closure and correct labelling. Record how changes to essential packaging specifications will be approved.

If either party expects goods-in-transit insurance to cover damage, check the policy for these shipments. Record who is insured, the route, exclusions, claim deadline, evidence requirements and excess, and assign who notifies the insurer and submits the claim. Insurance may offer recovery; its existence is not proof that a particular loss is covered.

Check the carrier's terms as well as the insurance policy. Australia Post's general terms say compensation for loss or damage in transit depends on Australia Post being at fault, and exclude damage where the item was not adequately packed or could not be appropriately packaged (Australia Post).

Agree where a damaged item may need to go for inspection, repair, return or safe disposal. Apply that process to the case only after assessing the item and the customer's rights.

The ACCC educates consumers and businesses about rights and responsibilities under consumer guarantees and accepts reports about businesses. It does not resolve individual disputes or give legal advice about a consumer's right to a repair, replacement or refund (ACCC). State and territory consumer protection agencies may also help if a business does not resolve the situation.

Review damage cases against the agreed process. If claims repeatedly fail because evidence or packing requirements are unclear, revise the relevant term and supplier instruction.

More from Returns & Refunds